What is cheaper: repair the appliance or buy a new one?

man is repairing dishwasher instead of buying new one
Home > Blog > What is cheaper: repair the appliance or buy a new one?

The household appliance industry is a cornerstone of American homes, with over 500 million units shipped across the country and a market value of $53.2 billion. Annually, households spend an average of $590 on these indispensable devices, from major appliances to smaller ones. But when these appliances falter, homeowners are left with a challenging question: when to repair an appliance or when to replace an appliance? This article demystifies the process, guiding you through when to buy vs when to repair appliances for the best balance of comfort and cost.

When to repair appliances?

Appliances crying out for attention often present symptoms such as unusual noises, decreased efficiency, or frequent cycling – clear indicators of when to repair an appliance. It’s important to realize that these signals may stem from inadequate maintenance, potentially leading to the more complex question of repair or replacement of appliances. For consistent upkeep and to avoid the need to buy or repair appliance, consider availing the services of professionals like Appliance Care of Atlanta.

Regular appliance maintenance offers numerous advantages that ease the decision-making process of when to replace or repair an appliance. It minimizes repair costs, allows for uninterrupted appliance use, and provides confidence against unexpected breakdowns. Furthermore, it facilitates more efficient energy consumption, leading to reduced electricity bills, and prolongs the service life of your appliances. With Appliance Care of Atlanta, you can maintain your appliances’ best look, and delay the dilemma of when to buy appliance by ensuring their longevity and reliability.

List of home appliance that is cheaper to repair

Solving dilemma of when to repair an appliance and when to replace an appliance, understanding the cost implications can help us make wise decisions. In some instances, giving our favorite home appliances a second life can be both financially and environmentally savvy. The question of repair or buy new appliance isn’t always a straightforward one, but let’s dive into some appliances where repair could be the more economical choice.

  • Dishwasher. The average cost to repair a dishwasher is $204, which is significantly less than the cost of a new entry-level offering from top-rated brands, which can cost upwards of $764. Especially if your dishwasher is relatively new, repair can be the smarter choice.
  • Cooktop. A new cooktop can start at around $500, while the average cost to repair your old one might cost you $260. The decision here can be a toss-up, highly dependent on the age and model of your existing cooktop. In some cases, repair might be the more cost-effective route.
  • Oven. Ovens can last more than a dozen years, and repairs cost $226 on average. In contrast, a brand-new oven can cost around $500. If your oven isn’t too old, opting for repair could be the more economical choice.
  • Dryer. The average cost to repair a clothes dryer is $209. A new washer/dryer combo from a reliable brand could cost anywhere between $800 to $1,600. If your dryer is in relatively good condition, repair could be a cost-saving choice.

When to buy new appliances?

While the repair or buy new appliance debate is common, there are clear indicators suggesting it’s time to buy an appliance. If repair costs exceed half the price of a new appliance, or if the appliance is over eight years old, replacement becomes a more sensible option. Increased energy bills, constant repairs, and obvious signs of wear and tear also signal it’s time to replace.

Choosing a new appliance is just the beginning — proper installation is critical. This is where Appliance Care of Atlanta shines, offering cost savings, safety, service life prolongation, and convenience. They ensure your appliance works efficiently and safely from the start, extending its lifespan and relieving you from the intricacies of the installation process. When navigating when to replace or repair an appliance predicament, remember the benefits of professional installation services.

List of home appliance that is cheaper to replace

Understanding when to buy vs when to repair appliances is essential for making an informed decision. Let’s delve into the list of appliances that are generally cheaper to replace than to repair:

  • Rangehood. The average repair bill for a rangehood runs $264. Unless you own a professional chef quality rangehood, replacing it with a new one for a similar price could be a better option1.
  • Microwave. According to consumer reports, the average microwave repair bill is $195, while a high-end new microwave can be purchased for about $120. It’s clear that in such a case, buying a new microwave is the smarter choice1.
  • Freezer. The average cost to repair a freezer is $348. However, a new freezer, like an Arctic King chest freezer, can be had for $169. This is a clear case of when a new purchase is more economical than a repair.

Appliance repair vs appliance replacement: pros and cons

Each option – whether it’s to repair, replace, or buy – carries with it its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Let’s shed some light on the pros and cons of each route.

Appliance Repair: The Pros and Cons


  • Cost-Effective. When considering when to repair an appliance, the first thing to assess is the cost. In many cases, repair costs are less than the price of a new unit, especially if the problem is minor.
  • Environmental Impact. Repairing an appliance extends its lifespan, thereby reducing waste and the overall environmental impact.
  • Preserve Matching Sets. If your appliance is part of a set, repairing the faulty unit can keep the aesthetic uniformity of your home intact.


  • Recurring Issues. Appliances that have been repaired might experience similar issues in the future. This can lead to a cycle of repairs, and eventually, the cumulative cost may exceed the price of a new unit.
  • Availability of Parts. Finding replacement parts for older models can be challenging and sometimes expensive.

Appliance Replacement: The Pros and Cons


  • New Features and Technology. Opting to buy a new appliance offers the chance to upgrade to a model with advanced features and better energy efficiency.
  • Warranty Coverage. New appliances often come with warranties, providing peace of mind and protection against future malfunctions.
  • Long-Term Savings. Although a new appliance might be a substantial upfront investment, it could save money in the long run by reducing energy costs and eliminating recurring repair bills.


  • Higher Initial Cost. When deciding when to buy appliance, the initial outlay is generally higher than the cost of a repair.
  • Environmental Impact. Replacing an appliance before the end of its helpful life contributes to electronic waste.
  • Installation Time and Cost. New appliances require installation, which may come with additional costs and require time.

In the end, the decision of repairing or replacing appliances comes down to the specific circumstances of your appliance and personal preference. Should you need expert assistance in making this decision, look no further than Appliance Care of Atlanta. Whether you choose to repair or install a new appliance, our team of professionals is equipped with the skills and experience to guide you through the process, ensuring you make the best decision for your home and budget.


Determining whether to repair or buy new appliance can be complex, contingent on factors such as the appliance’s type, age, and associated costs. Some appliances like vacuum cleaners and refrigerators typically lean towards repair, answering the question of when to repair an appliance. Conversely, rangehoods and microwaves often prove cheaper to replace, giving clarity to those considering when to buy appliance.

Regardless of whether you decide to repair or replace appliance, it’s vital to weigh the immediate costs, the appliance’s condition, and potential future savings. For professional guidance in this process, Appliance Care of Atlanta stands ready to help, ensuring you make the best decision for your household and budget.

Book a specialist to repair your appliance

Whether you’re facing the question of when to repair an appliance or when to replace an appliance, the professionals at Appliance Care of Atlanta can provide much-needed clarity and expertise. Their team of specialists is renowned for their extensive experience, capable of handling a wide array of appliance types and brands. When the decision to repair or buy new appliance feels overwhelming, remember that you don’t have to go through it alone.

Relying on Appliance Care of Atlanta isn’t just about getting your appliances fixed — it’s about joining a community of satisfied customers. The company takes pride in its glowing testimonials, reflecting its commitment to exceptional service. Whether it’s time to repair that old refrigerator or install a brand new dishwasher, Appliance Care of Atlanta is your trusted partner, ensuring a seamless process from start to finish.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *